Landed Cost vs FOB vs CIF: Which Number Should You Plan On?

The three numbers are not competing descriptions of the same thing. They are three stopping points on one line, and each of them is the right answer to a different question. FOB answers what the goods cost. CIF answers what it costs to get them to the port. Landed cost answers what they cost to have.

Programmes get into trouble by using one number for all three questions. A plan built on FOB understates the cost by more than half in the example below; a negotiation conducted on landed cost mixes production performance with freight market performance and hides both.

Rates, fee caps and programme lists are revised by the importing authority. Treat every percentage here as a planning range and confirm the line against the official tariff database or a written ruling before it goes into a selling price.

What Do FOB, CIF and Landed Cost Actually Mean?

FOB — free on board — means the seller delivers the goods on board the vessel at the named port, and the risk and the cost pass at that point. Under the Incoterms 2020 rules the term is meaningless without the named place: FOB Xiamen, not FOB China.

CIF — cost, insurance and freight — means the seller also contracts and pays for the carriage and the insurance to the destination port. The risk still passes on board at origin, which surprises people: CIF is a cost term, not a risk term.

Landed cost has no Incoterm behind it. It is the total cost of the goods at the point they are available for sale — the invoice value, the transport, the insurance, the duty, the fees, the brokerage, the inland delivery and the bank charges.

Where Does Each Number Stop?

The stopping points can be read off a single order. Take 500 pieces at FOB Xiamen USD 4.80. FOB is USD 2,400.00. Freight, terminal handling and booking come to USD 285.00 and marine insurance to USD 8.10, so CIF is USD 2,693.10. Duty at an illustrative 17.6% is USD 422.40, origin-based duty at an illustrative 7.5% is USD 180.00, the merchandise processing fee is USD 32.71 at its floor, the harbour maintenance fee is USD 3.00, broker and filing USD 145.00, and drayage and delivery USD 210.00.

That gives a landed total of USD 3,686.21, or USD 7.37 a unit. The uplift over FOB is USD 2.57 a unit — a little over half the FOB price — and only USD 0.59 of it is freight and insurance.

Why Is FOB the Quoting Number and Not the Planning Number?

Because it is the number the production side controls and can be held to. Freight rates move with the market, duty rates move with policy, and quoting on a number that includes both makes it impossible to tell whether a change came from the factory or from the world.

FOB Xiamen is also the number that matches the payment arrangement. Under T/T 30/70 the deposit and the balance are percentages of the goods value, not of the landed cost. Keeping the quotation on FOB keeps the commercial documents, the payment schedule and the production discussion on the same figure.

What Does CIF Add and What Does It Still Leave Out?

CIF adds the carriage and the insurance to the destination port, and no more. It does not include duty, it does not include the entry fees, it does not include the inland delivery, and it does not include the bank charges on the transfers. The goods can arrive at the port and still be a long way from saleable.

It is also the number that most often misleads, because it sounds complete and is not. A buyer comparing a CIF quotation with a selling price is comparing a port cost with a shop price, and the gap between them is the duty stack.

Why Does the Duty Base Differ Between the Three?

Because markets choose their own base. The United States generally uses the transaction value, which on an FOB sale is the FOB value, and excludes international freight and insurance where they are identified separately. Most other markets — the European Union, the United Kingdom, Australia, the Gulf states — use CIF.

That difference is arithmetic rather than policy drama, but it is money. On this order the US base is USD 2,400.00 and the CIF base is USD 2,693.10. The same illustrative 17.6% produces USD 422.40 in one market and USD 473.99 in the other: USD 51.59, or USD 0.10 a unit, purely from where the base is drawn.

Which Number Should the Selling Price Be Built On?

Landed cost, without exception, because a selling price is compared with a fully costed unit. Building a price on FOB and treating the rest as overhead is the commonest way a programme discovers, a quarter in, that its margin was never there.

The discipline is to keep the three separate but reconciled: quote and pay on FOB, plan the duty with the HS line, and hold a landed unit cost that is recomputed whenever a rate, a freight quote or an order size changes. Price the whole stack in one place rather than in three spreadsheets.

What Does Each Number Do to a Reorder?

There is a fourth number that appears in practice and causes confusion: the delivered-duty-paid quotation. It is not a fourth stopping point, it is the landed cost quoted by the seller rather than computed by the buyer, and the difference is who carries the risk on the duty being right. Where a delivered quotation is used, the classification decision moves with it.

A reorder is where the difference compounds, because a repeat run is usually ordered on the remembered number rather than the computed one. Freight has moved, the fee floor may no longer bind, and the order size may have changed; all three move the landed unit cost while leaving the FOB price where it was.

That is why the FOB price is the number to hold constant and the landed cost is the number to recompute. Holding the landed cost constant across cycles is an assumption, and it is the assumption that quietly loses money. Reorder consistency covers the production side of the same point.

How Do Payment Terms Interact With the Three?

T/T 30/70 splits the goods value into a deposit and a balance, and both are computed on FOB. On this order the deposit is USD 720.00 and the balance is USD 1,680.00. The freight, the duty and the delivery fall later and are settled against different documents.

Two bank transfers each carry a charge, and those charges belong in the landed cost rather than in the unit price. Two transfers at an illustrative USD 32.00 each is USD 64.00 on the order, or USD 0.13 a unit — small, fixed, and always forgotten.

What About the Money That Comes Back?

Import VAT and goods and services tax are recoverable by a registered importer in most markets, so they are a cash-flow item rather than a cost. Duty paid on goods that are exported again is recoverable through drawback in the United States. Both are real and neither belongs in a unit cost that is being compared with a price.

The rule of thumb: cost what you keep, and finance what you recover. A landed cost model that includes recoverable tax overstates the cost just as badly as one that omits the duty understates it.

What Happens When the Order Size Changes?

FOB scales linearly, CIF scales in steps, and landed cost falls per unit. Freight is quoted by container or by consignment rather than by piece, drayage and brokerage are largely fixed, and the fee floor stops binding above a threshold value. Every one of those pushes the unit landed cost down as the order grows.

On the same unit price: 300 pieces land at USD 8.27 a unit, 500 at USD 7.37, 1,000 at USD 6.82 and 2,000 at USD 6.58. The goods did not get less expensive; the fixed costs spread.

How Does This Fit the Production Schedule?

The landed cost can be computed before the goods are made, and should be. Sampling runs 6-10 working days and bulk runs 35-50 days from written sample approval, which is more than enough time to settle the line, confirm the rate and get a freight quote on the actual carton count.

What cannot be computed early is the freight, which is quoted against the market and the packing. Use a range and update it when the packing list is final, at inspection under AQL 2.5 and ISO 2859-1, when the carton count and the weights are known rather than estimated.

What Is the Practical Bottom Line?

Quote on FOB, plan on landed, and never let the two drift apart without somebody noticing. On a 500-piece order the gap is more than half the unit price, and the parts of it that are hardest to see — the fee floor, the fixed brokerage, the two bank charges — are the parts that do not appear in a rate table.

Everything else is the standard shape: MOQ 500 pcs, sampling 6-10 working days, bulk 35-50 days from written sample approval, inspection at AQL 2.5 under ISO 2859-1, T/T 30/70, FOB Xiamen. Three numbers, one schedule, and one of them is the one to plan on.

Frequently Asked Questions

People Also Ask